Speed, alcohol questioned in deadly crash case


By Anna Bolton - abolton@aimmediamidwest.com



Anna Bolton | Greene County News Defense Attorney Peter Certo and defendant Kathy Smith turn to look at a photo marked as evidence Jan. 28 during trial as Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Jaysen Kelly testifies. Judge Stephen Wolaver looks on.

Anna Bolton | Greene County News Defense Attorney Peter Certo and defendant Kathy Smith turn to look at a photo marked as evidence Jan. 28 during trial as Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Jaysen Kelly testifies. Judge Stephen Wolaver looks on.


XENIA — Audience members cried quietly on the benches in Courtroom One Jan. 28 as a woman identified a photo of her late husband, killed in the rainy back-road two-vehicle accident that she survived three summers ago.

“That’s my husband, Raymond,” Linda Deyo, 68, said on the witness stand before the jury inside Greene County’s courthouse.

Nearly two and a half years after the deadly crash, the driver of the second vehicle is on trial. Kathy Smith, 65, of Xenia, is charged with two counts of aggravated vehicular homicide, second-degree and third-degree felonies, one count with mandatory imprisonment; two counts of aggravated vehicular assault, third-degree and fourth-degree felonies; and operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol and/or other drugs, a first-degree misdemeanor.

The Bowersville couple was headed home from an auction Aug. 27, 2016, Deyo testified, and had turned onto Hussey Road in Caesar Creek Township when their 2004 Toyota Tundra was hit. It was raining, Deyo said. Her husband, Raymond Deyo, 68, was driving.

“I didn’t see it comin’, didn’t feel the impact,” Linda Deyo said. “I woke up and we were sitting there in the truck. He was sitting like this — and I said, ‘Ray, what happened?’ and he never answered.”

Deyo said she woke up next in a Kettering hospital with a concussion, broken pelvis and bruised ribs. She said she also had her gallbladder removed, back surgery, and hernia surgery.

“I feel pain every day somewhere on my body. I’m not normal, but I’m back to pretty good,” Deyo said. “I’ll never be the same.”

During trial this week, attorneys are disputing whether or not Smith, who also suffered injuries, was intoxicated or driving recklessly at the time of the collision.

According to Assistant Prosecutor David Morrison, Smith’s Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) was .343.

“We believe the evidence will show that Ms. Smith was intoxicated and she was, in fact, driving recklessly,” Morrison said to the jury.

Defense Attorney Peter Certo, in his opening arguments, agreed that Smith’s BAC was recorded as four times the legal limit, .08, for driving in Ohio.

Certo said later in the trial, an independent doctor who reviewed Smith’s medical records will testify that the blood alcohol test was “a bad test” and that it is “medically impossible” for her to have had that BAC at the time of the accident.

“So why are we here?” Certo asked. “We are here because the evidence will also show that the gentleman she was with just a few minutes before the crash said there was no alcohol involved. The evidence will show that the woman who came out of the house to tend to Ms. Smith right after the accident made no observations of alcohol — no slurred speech, no odor of alcohol, no alcohol containers in the car … And the medics, who are trained to look for these kinds of symptoms — the evidence will show that they noted nothing.”

Certo said Smith, when asked if she had had anything to drink, answered “wine.”

“When they spoke with her she was oriented by four — oriented to time, oriented to place, oriented to person, oriented to events,” Certo said. “She had her wits about her. She gave appropriate responses. Even with her one word answer, ‘wine’, with all those other indicators, they made no assessment in regard to alcohol involved.”

Along with the medics, Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Jaysen Kelly responded to the scene. Kelly, who reconstructed the crash, testified that based on the severity of the damage to both vehicles and the conditions of the roadway, he believed that Deyo’s truck had been traveling eastbound at 40-45 mph and Smith’s Chevy Cruze had been traveling westbound at 67-77 mph. That stretch of Hussey Road has a 55 mph speed limit, according to the trooper.

Kelly said his reconstruction also led him to conclude that the Chevy Cruze had gone left of center. He said if there had been any standing water on the roadway — which he couldn’t determine — then that likely would have caused a hydroplaning effect based on the Chevy’s speed and tire tread.

“She hit water,” Certo had said earlier to the jury. “She lost control of the vehicle and went across center.”

Photos, marked as evidence and put up on the screen for the courtroom to see, showed a red compact car in a field, its doors open, its entire front crushed, its engine lying several feet away. And a white pickup truck across the road, air bags deployed, left bumper crushed, its driver’s side door out of place.

The state will continue presenting testimony 8:30 a.m. Tuesday, Jan. 29 in Judge Stephen Wolaver’s courtroom.

Anna Bolton | Greene County News Defense Attorney Peter Certo and defendant Kathy Smith turn to look at a photo marked as evidence Jan. 28 during trial as Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Jaysen Kelly testifies. Judge Stephen Wolaver looks on.
https://www.xeniagazette.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2019/01/web1_CertoSmith.jpgAnna Bolton | Greene County News Defense Attorney Peter Certo and defendant Kathy Smith turn to look at a photo marked as evidence Jan. 28 during trial as Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Jaysen Kelly testifies. Judge Stephen Wolaver looks on.

By Anna Bolton

abolton@aimmediamidwest.com